Watery Cakeism: a lifeline for the poor River Darent?

An ingenious proposal from water-resource engineer John Lawson could restore flows to two of England’s most over-abstracted chalk streams, decades earlier than currently planned, and save billions of pounds in the process. What’s not to like?

Regular readers of this blog will know of the work of John Lawson. He is the brains behind our Chalk Streams First concept for relocating abstraction in chalk streams without waiting donkeys years for expensive infrastructure. John is a very much untapped asset in our national water resource planning. He is a retired engineer – and a very clever one – with a long and celebrated career in the sector behind him. Our problem is that his ideas are counterintuitive and to some degree upset the water industry and regulatory establishment.

The idea I unpack below could be his best yet: it could save a river and save bill-payers billions. It has wider implications too, for chalk streams beyond the Darent and Cray, which I will explore in a follow on post. Surely, this time, John’s ideas will be listened to and acted on?

The Rivers Darent and Cray in Kent have the unhappy distinction of being among the most over-abstracted chalk streams in England. More than thirty years after the National Rivers Authority launched its River Darent Action Plan, the two rivers are still chronically short of water. In dry weather, flows can fall to a tenth of what they would naturally be. Parts of the Darent dry up altogether.

This is a tragedy. The Darent was once one of the most celebrated trout streams in the country. Special trains would take anglers from London to Kent for fishing festivals in which thousands of trout were caught. See the Classic Angler feature below. You’d have trouble wetting a line on the river today.

The problem is not a mystery. Far too much groundwater is taken from the aquifers that feed these rivers, leaving too little behind to flow from their springs. There have been some small reductions in abstraction over the years, but nowhere near enough. The amount of water still abstracted from the upper and middle catchments is about 61% of their average annual groundwater recharge.

The water companies and the Environment Agency admit that this is a problem. Their current plans envisage large-scale reductions in abstraction, totalling approximately 158 million litres per day (Ml/d). Sure …. if delivered, these would restore flows in the Darent and Cray to something approaching their natural condition.

That’s a move on from where we were years ago but its still not great because most of these reductions are not planned until after 2050. And if you think they’ll happen then, as planned, you’ve got another think coming.

The water industry argues that it cannot stop taking water from the Darent aquifers until alternative sources have been developed. Much of the replacement supply is expected to come from Thames Water’s proposed £6.6 billion reservoir near Abingdon, in Oxfordshire, together with the pipelines and other infrastructure necessary to transfer water into the Darent catchment.

There is, very plausibly, another better, faster and cheaper way of approaching the problem.

A different solution

John Lawson is a highly experienced water-resource engineer who has worked with Chalk Streams First and numerous local river groups to investigate the impacts of groundwater abstraction. His work on the Kennet, the Chilterns chalk streams, the Ivel and the Tarrant will be familiar to regular readers of this blog.

Earlier this year, John was commissioned by the Darent River Preservation Society, South East Rivers Trust and Darent Valley Trout Fishers to investigate the effects of abstraction on the Darent and Cray and consider whether there might be a quicker, less expensive way of restoring their flows.

His report, Re-naturalising flows in the Rivers Darent and Cray, released to the regulators in May this year (2026), has some striking conclusions.

The most important is that it should be possible to restore the rivers to something very close to their natural flow regimes, in most years, without waiting for Abingdon reservoir or other major new water-resource schemes. The answer lies in something called conjunctive use.

This sounds techie, but the principle is straightforward. Rather than using one source of water continuously, conjunctive use varies the sources we use according to circumstances. Conceptually it is something the industry is actually quite keen on. If anything it is our side, the environmental advocacy side of the discussion, that resist the idea, mostly because the science behind the idea is counter-intuitive. In the case of chalk streams, John’s conjunctive scheme abstracts during a drought!

But stick with me because you’ll get it … Listen to where the water is coming from and when.

London’s water supply comes principally from the Thames and Lee, with substantial reservoir storage to maintain supplies during droughts. For much of the time, flows in these rivers are sufficient to meet London’s needs without drawing heavily upon its reservoir reserves.

Meanwhile, groundwater is continuously being pumped from the Darent and Cray aquifers, even when London has ample surface water available.

John’s proposal is to join these two systems together more effectively.

In normal conditions, water currently taken from the Darent and Cray would instead be supplied from London’s existing water resources. The groundwater pumps would be switched off, allowing aquifer levels to recover and the rivers to flow.

When a drought threatens London’s water supplies, the arrangement would be reversed. The Darent and Cray boreholes would be brought back into operation, reducing the demand on London’s increasingly scarce surface water.

Once the drought was over, pumping would stop again and the aquifers would recover.

In other words, instead of continuously exploiting the groundwater, we would conserve it as a reserve for when it is really needed, during a drought, which is when London’s supply is truly under threat.

This is not an entirely new idea. A smaller conjunctive-use arrangement between London and the Darent was considered in the 1990s, but never significantly implemented. John’s work develops the principle on a much larger scale and tests its potential using detailed modelling of both the groundwater system and London’s water supplies.

What difference would it make to the chalk streams? It sounds like abstracting in a drought could make them even worse? Wrong.

John has developed a version of the Chalk Streams First groundwater model to simulate the response of the Darent and Cray aquifers to changes in abstraction.

The modelling distinguishes between the Greensand aquifer of the upper Darent and the Chalk aquifer feeding the middle and lower Darent and the Cray. It reproduces the observed relationship between groundwater levels and river flows, and its results compare favourably with those produced by the Environment Agency’s more complex London Basin Model.

One finding is particularly important.

During the 1990s and early 2000s, groundwater abstraction from the upper and middle catchments was reduced by approximately 26 Ml/d. Analysis of recorded river flows shows that most of this reduction translated into increased river flow. This is significant because the relatively modest ecological improvements seen since then have sometimes been interpreted as evidence that reducing abstraction does not achieve very much. John’s analysis suggests otherwise. The abstraction reductions worked. They simply weren’t large enough.

His new proposal considers switching 84 Ml/d of existing groundwater supplies in the upper and middle Darent and Cray to drought-only operation. The modelling predicts that groundwater levels would typically rise by about a metre, approaching their natural levels, and that river flows would be fully or nearly restored for most of the time.

Even in significant droughts, when the boreholes would have to be brought back into service, river flows would remain substantially better than they are under the present system of continuous pumping.

After a major drought, the aquifers would take approximately 18 months to recover fully.

There is, of course, more to a healthy river than water alone. Historical modification of the river channels, pollution and other pressures must also be addressed. But a river cannot express its ecological potential without sufficient flow, and the scale of the predicted recovery is considerable.

What about London’s water supplies?

This is where John’s work becomes especially interesting.

Replacing 84 Ml/d of groundwater abstraction in the Darent and Cray with water from London might sound like it would put a substantial additional burden on London’s resources. But it’s a question of when that water would be required.

The Darent would be supplied from London when water was relatively plentiful. As drought conditions developed, the Darent boreholes would be brought into operation, conserving London’s surface-water resources.

Essentially we are dealing with two kinds of water storage: the man-made reservoirs of London and the natural reservoirs under the ground in Kent upon which the chalk streams rely. John’s proposal switches around which type is used when, meaning the rivers get to flow naturally, but London still has emergency storage in the form of the chalk aquifer.

John has modelled this arrangement against the historical operation of London’s water-supply system, including the severe 1933–34 drought.

His calculations suggest that the loss of London’s reliable supply capacity — what water engineers call deployable output — would be a minimal 7 Ml/d. This kind of pocket change can be found under any number of sofas: demand reduction, recycling, leak reduction etc. It is an extraordinarily small reduction in London’s drought-resilient supply capacity compared with the 84 Ml/d of groundwater abstraction that could be avoided most of the time.

The scheme would also preserve the existing groundwater sources as an important strategic reserve. They would not be abandoned, as envisaged under the water companies’ current long-term plans.

This is environmental cake-ism of the best kind. What’s not to like?

Okay, the analysis is early doors. The effects of more extreme droughts, including the 1-in-500-year events against which water companies must now plan (a really stupid stricture, by the way), and of future climate change have yet to be tested fully. There are also practical questions about water quality, engineering capacity and operating agreements.

How much would it cost, and how soon could it happen?

There’s some money to spend. New connections would be needed between London’s supply network and areas currently served by the Darent and Cray groundwater sources, together with improvements to the existing treatment and distribution infrastructure. John reckons that these works could cost several hundred million pounds. But this money would have to be spent anyway to enable the existing longer term plans. His proposal is simply to bring that investment forward.

More importantly, John’s analysis suggests that the scheme could avoid the need for approximately 150 Ml/d of additional strategic water-resource development elsewhere, saving several billion pounds.

His proposal also leaves some 76 Ml/d of lower Darent and Cray abstractions operating continuously, subject to further investigation of their effects on river flows. Because this abstraction is taken much further down the catchment where the water table is more stable, it is probable that the impact on flows is much less significant. Those sources could also be incorporated into the conjunctive-use scheme if necessary.

John proposes completing detailed investigations by 2029, establishing a pilot using existing network connections around 2030, delivering at least half the scheme’s potential by 2035, and completing the full scheme by 2040.

That would bring major environmental improvements forward by approximately fifteen years, and potentially more in the case of a pilot.

Where next?

John’s modelling needs to be tested against the water companies’ own resource models. The effects of lower-catchment abstractions need further investigation, as do the practicalities of switching supplies and ensuring resilience in extreme droughts.

But one of the most compelling aspects of John’s report is that it challenges the assumption that restoring the Darent and Cray must wait for the construction of an entirely new strategic water source, like Abingdon. Instead, it asks whether existing resources could be operated more intelligently. In the existing approach, groundwater is taken continuously from environmentally sensitive aquifers, while new infrastructure is planned to replace it. In John’s approach, the same aquifers become part of the solution, providing valuable drought resilience while remaining sufficiently full to sustain healthy rivers for most of the time.

The Darent and Cray have been ruined by abstraction for over 50 years. Why should we wait for many more decades to pass before doing something about it, when an answer is there for the taking? Surely, this is an idea worth formal investigation with some urgency?

I’ll explore the encouraging wider implications in a follow on post.

Five years on …

It’s hard to believe it’s been five years since we published the CaBA Chalk Stream Restoration Strategy (October 2021), and even longer, therefore, since we started work on it. Perhaps this is a good opportunity to look back and reflect on what the project has achieved thus far: the encouraging progress and the disappointing lack of it.

There will always be disappointment. We should take that as read. It is wrong to imagine some Damascene moment on the road to environmental salvation. That would be to underestimate the scale and complexity of the problems, and perhaps overestimate the enthusiasm of the powers that be to actually address them! Chalk streams are under such pressure from so many quarters that the brutal truth is we could run fast just to stand still. Sometimes it feels like that’s all we’re doing.

However … the encouraging progress is there to see, too, if you know where and how to look. How to look is key. For that we need honesty in all directions: recognising that as much as Defra can be obstructively bureaucratic and timid, it can also initiate really good schemes and policies that are – slowly but surely – improving things. Or that as much as some farming practice can be really damaging to chalk streams, there are also loads of farmers very keen to make a positive impact. Or that as much as water companies sweat their infrastructure and dissemble over the impacts of abstraction, they are also funding lots of good restoration work.

We need to be as willing to recognise improvement where it exists as we are to condemn regression or stasis. The two pictures below shows the range of condition that can exist: things aren’t too bad on Hertfordshire’s Mimram (right), but just a few miles away the upper reaches of the Lea are a sorry sight.

When Mark Lloyd, Sarah Powell at the EA and Minister Rebecca Pow asked me in 2020 to help formulate a national strategy to drive chalk stream restoration, a few people – including me – were pretty cynical. It wasn’t as if we didn’t already know what to do to help chalk streams. It would be a six-word strategy, I said: “More Water, Less Poo, Better Habitat”.

Some might even have felt that joining such an initiative was to facilitate the same old, same old lack of progress; that what we really needed was litigation and protest, fire and brimstone. But wild trout and dragonflies don’t much care how you improve things, or even who you talk to in order to make it happen. They simply care that you do it.

So, I agreed, on the condition that “action” would be part of this action plan. I even undertook an analysis of all the chalk stream action plans that had preceded this one, of all the things that had been asked for and the rather fewer things that had been achieved.

So, when in 2024 Defra, under the camouflage of a change of government, completely buried the chalk stream policy document Ali More and I had spent the previous 12 months writing with them, I did feel we had been very badly let down. Defra had proved the naysayers correct. Not that the naysayers had achieved anything either!

River restoration is the work of Sisyphus.

BUT, BUT, BUT … just look at the River Wandle … or the River Chess. Those cases, and others, show what a combination of dogged protest AND positive community effort can achieve over time.

About 20 years ago I made a little film with the BBC about a quest to find a wild trout in London. It was a history of London’s rivers, an exploration of the landscape that existed before the metropolis had gobbled it up, and a somewhat romantic search for hope in the form of a wild trout, to see if one might possibly exist in one of those London streams.

I’d heard rumours of trout in the River Wandle, but neither on my own nor with the BBC charabanc in tow did I find one. I tried other parts of London, chasing the ghosts and whispers of rumour, until finally we ended up on the lower reaches of the River Chess near Rickmansworth, inside the M25 if not quite inside London.

I hunted the diminished and slightly odorous flows of that beleaguered stream through the Rickmansworth playing fields at Scotsbridge and all the way upstream until the M25 was a stone’s throw away, before finally catching one very small wild trout on a dry fly, in the grounds of a garden centre.

My quest realised, I said something to camera about the pressure society exerts on these natural wonder rivers – the Chess was very heavily abstracted at the time and no phosphorus was removed from its sewage works – and that if only we made a bit more effort, we’d see dozens of wild trout like this one.

Today, the River Wandle has lots of wild trout in it, along with more prolific numbers of the barbel and chub that were there – just about – at the turn of the millennium. The Chess meanwhile is another success story. It is FULL of wild trout. Its flows are restored almost to natural. Within another few years there will be zero abstraction on the River Chess. And the sewage works at the upper end, about which Paul Jennings has so tirelessly protested, has now been upgraded to “highest technical standards”. Meanwhile Paul and his colleagues are restoring meanders and allowing the habitat to naturalise.

The Chess is now exactly what I hoped it would become that day down at the garden centre. A wild corridor in the midst of our heavily populated landscape.

I could cite many other good news stories – my local stream, the River Nar, for example. The Piddle in Dorset. The River Pang.

It would be disingenuous to say these are all down to the CaBA strategy. These are examples, however, of a general drift of improvement that has gathered pace since the nadir days of the late 1980s, of which the CaBA work is now a part and – I would argue – an important, catalysing part.

One BIG thing emerged out of researching and writing the original 2021 strategy: a universally cited need for a higher designation for chalk streams. Everyone, from all sides, said that with a designation like SSSI or SAC status, the cost-effectiveness tests and other barriers to progress would be lowered, or at least eased. This could be quite easily demonstrated by comparing the proportion of sewage works that removed phosphorus on SSSI and SAC chalk streams against the rest, or by comparing abstraction rates on the more protected streams with those on the others.

We also showed that, strangely enough, all chalk streams had once (in the early noughties) enjoyed an elevated designation as “priority habitats”, with their own economic drivers, but that this status had been deflated by Natural England, which had for some reason performed the ecological equivalent of quantitative easing by making many other river types “priority habitats”, and then quantitative tightening by implying that most chalk streams didn’t now fall into that new definition.

So, we pushed and pushed and pushed for some sort of revival of a priority status UNIQUE TO CHALK STREAMS. Minister Rebecca Pow wanted to see it. Very senior people at the Environment Agency and Natural England wanted to see it. But somehow the entreaties entered a sort of bureaucratic black hole somewhere near Whitehall, from which they never emerged.

Finally, Minister Pow commissioned a government response to this ONE BIG WISH: a Defra policy document that Ali Morse and I then spent the next 12 months negotiating with shape-shifting Defra officials.

It was like an extended version of Groundhog Day. The document was finished by its promised deadline, but the staff were shuffled and we had to start again. And again. And then the election was called and the policy document was shelved.

Teeth-grindingly frustrating … but not quite a waste of time.

What became apparent to me through this process was that higher status, of itself, doesn’t necessarily achieve anything. It is the practical protections that come with higher status that really matter. Sure, you can collate them all together and give them a badge, but you don’t actually have to do that in order to make the components effective.

Chalk streams had acquired their own badge anyway, and no one at Marsham Street could do anything about that. Chalk streams had far more status in the public consciousness than at any point in history. David Attenborough had cited them as wonders of the natural world in his groundbreaking series about nature in the British Isles. Social media was abuzz with concern for these globally unique rivers.

So, focusing on the practical components: we needed regulatory and policy drivers that would primarily help to reduce abstraction and improve sewage treatment. Secondarily, we needed greater protection in planning law and landscape management.

And we got some of that.

  1. Chalk streams were singled out as priority sites in the stormwater reduction plan, placing them on a similar footing to SAC and SSSI sites when it comes to addressing sewage overflows.
  2. The National Framework for Water Resources identified chalk streams as a priority for action to address unsustainable abstraction. It sounds opaquely bureaucratic, but balancing water resources for people with the needs of the environment is going to be a very big challenge over the coming decades. Chalk streams will now get special consideration in that balancing act.
  3. The National Planning Policy Framework now cites chalk streams as important habitats that need protection.
  4. Specific chalk stream measures are included in the Government’s Environmental Improvement Plan.
  5. Chalk streams are specifically considered in most Local Nature Recovery Strategies covering the chalk stream network.

Time will tell if and how that all amounts to greater protection and restoration, but in 2024–25 an extra 69 sewage treatment works on chalk streams received upgrades to remove phosphorus. By 2030 over 50% of sewage works on chalk streams will treat to tertiary level. In 2021 the equivalent proportion on SSSIs was about 70% and on SACs about 80%. So, the groundwork is laid and there are signs of progress.

I would still like to see the badge, however, with chalk streams receiving their own unique category of Priority Status to reflect their globally unique natural heritage.

Elsewhere, progress has been made with the nine flagship catchment restorations we started, designed to demonstrate the art of the possible in terms of joined-up restoration, planning and execution.

The thinking here was that with such complex pressures across the board, it simply isn’t possible to do everything, everywhere, all at once. But examples of what is possible would show that if you push hard enough, for long enough, at a local level, you can make a difference.

The River Chess is a perfect example, where water quality and quantity pressures have been successfully addressed alongside physical habitat improvement.

Similar work is ongoing on the River Anton, the Frome, the Beane, the Granta, the Ems, the Lark, the Hull and the Great Stour.

The River Anton flagship work at Westfair: restoring the perched and diverted river to its natural place in the floodplain.

To these flagship projects has been added a new Defra initiative that may prove equally valuable in the long term: Landscape Recovery. There are a number of really exciting whole-catchment restorations in the pipeline on rivers like the Darent in Kent, the Allen in Dorset and, in Norfolk, the Babingley, Nar and Heacham, as well as the much-neglected little Gaywood.

I’ve been involved in the design of projects on these Norfolk streams and know that if they get the Defra thumbs-up, we could see source-to-sea renaturalisation of floodplains and channels, and even the relocation of abstraction along the lines of the Chalk Streams First idea I have so often championed.

On that note, we also have signs of progress – in the Chilterns at least – where Affinity Water has partially embraced the idea of rolling abstraction down the chalk stream catchments, leaving more water to drive aquifer flows in the headwaters, knowing that it can be recovered for public water supply in the lower reaches of the Colne.

As I reported HERE, actual reductions in abstraction, expressed as a percentage of the previous volume and in megalitres per day (Ml/d), have amounted to:

  • Hughenden Stream – a 100% reduction of 1.6 Ml/d
  • Misbourne – a 50% reduction of 13 Ml/d
  • Upper Chess – a 100% reduction of 6.38 Ml/d
  • Upper Gade – a 31% reduction of 6.4 Ml/d
  • Ver – a 67% reduction of 28 Ml/d
  • Upper Lea – a 27% reduction of 10.2 Ml/d
  • Hiz and Oughton – a 13% reduction of 1.3 Ml/d
  • Mimram – a 50% reduction of 9 Ml/d
  • Beane – a 70% reduction of 16 Ml/d

Finally, there’s the work to coalesce the enthusiasm and develop the expertise of a growing army of chalk stream enthusiasts.

When we put together the strategy I was amazed by how much of the data critical to understanding how to strategise action, or hold authorities to account, was hidden behind opaque walls of officialdom. Abstraction, for example: all we knew was whether a river’s flow did or did not support good ecological status. We had no idea by how much targets were being missed, or to what extent flows, such as they were, were supported by sewage discharges.

That lack of information can lead us in the wrong directions.

For example, on Norfolk’s River Wensum I’ve recently been arguing, because I have looked into the data, that groundwater abstraction is not at the scale people think. The biggest brake on the recovery of that river is the totally shagged habitat. The River Ivel, on the other hand, is completely destroyed by groundwater abstraction, in spite of the official record showing that its flows support good ecological status.

Bit by bit, if we build and support the chalk stream community and arm it with information, as Alison Matthews has been doing so brilliantly, we will become much more focused and effective in our efforts to restore these streams.

I actually think this may be the biggest contribution of all.

Thanks to Alison we now have a lively community to share thoughts and lessons with via the CaBA chalk stream hub and the regular webinars that she so energetically organises.

There is an amazing network of groups, organisations, volunteers, landowners and individuals who value and care for chalk streams. They invest huge amounts of time and money into improving them.

Champions of the River Chess, Paul Jennings and Kate Heppell, sharing knowledge with Uffe Westerberg who is working on the Danish chalk streams

Five years on, then, we have much to be pleased about, much to be frustrated by, and an enormous amount still to do. I don’t think any of us imagined that writing a national strategy would suddenly transform the fortunes of our chalk streams. The problems are too deeply embedded for that. But I do think we have helped to change the direction of travel, and perhaps more importantly, helped to equip the people who care about these rivers with better tools to change it further.

River restoration may be the work of Sisyphus, but at least we have a growing number of people pushing the boulder. And sometimes, if you look carefully, it really does move uphill.

XYZ

In the last post I outlined a simple way of trying put together a sensibly ordered catchment restoration strategy by scoring the underlying foundations at a reach scale – habitat, flow and water quality – working out where the deficits are, working out the feasibility of addressing each of them, multiplying one by the other and arriving at a strategic order of projects.

A few of the other slides I showed to the Test and Itchen group outlined in broad-brush terms how it might look at a catchment level with a look at the River Anton as an example. I’ll put those slides in the next post.

The first thing to look at in a little more detail, however, is the underlying foundation of physical habitat, that can be broken down into three physical dimensions that I call the XYZ. Lateral (X) and longitudinal (Y) connectivity and planform (Z). In my view, these foundational elements are THE most important thing of all, because they very largely determine whether and to what extent a dynamic, varied habitat can form (all the pools, riffles, undercuts etc).

Most chalk streams have been modified in ways that remove or undermine the XYZ.

X

X is the lateral connectivity with the riparian edge and the wider floodplain. A consistent feature of natural (unmodified) spring-creek (groundwater dominated) streams is the close relationship between the stream bed and the floodplain surface. Chalk streams are the same, or should be. Simply put, when you stand on the hypothetical unmodified banks of a spring-fed creek your feet won’t be that much higher than the water surface (summer or winter) and the river bed is not that far down below that water surface either, at least not compared to a surface-fed system with a much wider range between low flows and high flows.

To illustrate what I mean, here are some pictures of relatively unmodified spring-creeks, in Wyoming, Montana and New Zealand. You can see how these streams are flush full and in touch with their floodplains, and that they are free-flowing too: the flushness is not because they’ve been backed up in any way. They tend to be quite wide and shallow (lacking the energy to erode downwards) and they flow from and through a high-water table. Generally speaking chalk streams should look like that, but many to most don’t because they have been diverted and / or dredged.

Y

Y is the longitudinal connectivity – along the line of the channel. A natural chalk stream would likely feature hardly any major steps or interruptions in its longitudinal profile. Maybe beaver dams would create some steps, but in a undeveloped floodplain these would cause break-outs of flow around the sides, and one way or another the stream would travel unimpeded by large steps from the source to the sea.

Humans radically changed all that when we invented milling. The Romans will have blocked and impounded some of our chalk streams but we really went to town on them after the 8th century, so much so that by the time William the Conqueror invaded, we had over 5000 watermills in England and most were on lowland streams, including chalk streams, which are very easy to manipulate and dam.

To make a mill work on a lowland stream these early water engineers diverted the channel to the edge of the floodplain and ran it along a much shallower gradient than the natural valley. This built up the head of water required to turn the mill-wheel. If the valley gradient is 1:600, say, it takes 600 meters to build up a meter of head. Many chalk streams had reached mill saturation point by 1066. This is when you can’t fit any more in: the entire stream had been made into a staircase. For example, most of the natural gradient of the River Wensum, in Norfolk, is taken up by mills. This – and the legacy of dredging – is by far the most significant ecological stress on the river, even today.

To the mill diversions have been added many other forms of channel manipulation over history: navigational channels, locks, and the intricate system of hatches, carriers and catch-drains of the Jacobean to early Victorian water-meadow revolution. All of these modifications interrupt the natural slope of the stream.

Z

Z is the planform of the river, its shape seen from above. The natural, meandering planform of our chalk streams was radically modified as part and parcel of the many and various ways in which the streams were changed over the centuries, whether they were diverted to make mill leats or watermeadow carriers or ornamental lakes.

Almost everywhere chalk streams have been moved to the edges of their floodplains. If you look closely at modern stream pathways and the associated ditches and drains in the floodplain, you will see the main modern river running along one edge of the floodplain and then the other, while down the middle of the floodplain run a series of ditches that drain down to the crossing point. This was a widely practiced way of moving the river off the floodplain to make space for grazing and to lower the water-table too. In some settings it’s part of the milling and watermeadow pattern and in others, a feature in its own right.

But even when the modern river still more or less occupies the middle of the floodplain (which is rare) you will find that meanders have been straightened out, because for one reason or another the landowners wanted to get the stream out of the way and / or lower the bed of the river and improve drainage.

XYZ and the impacts of changing them

Generally speaking any of the significant ways in which chalk stream channels have been altered (mills, watermeadows, farm drainage, urban development and dredging) will have changed all the X,Y and Z dimensions in one go and the thus damaging impacts are layered and interwoven.

Take milling: to make a mill leat the channel has to be progressively raised above the natural fall-line of the valley. This robs the river of gradient and energy, isolates the river from the floodplain, divorces the channel from the water-table, and erases natural meanders. Essentially it takes a naturally dynamic, heterogenous physical structure where the river supports a mosaic of habitat niches and homogenises it in a more stagnant and imprisoned state, from which a chalk stream cannot escape.

People may wonder what the big difference is between a meandering channel and a straight channel. All the difference in the world! Meandering channels are so much more physically complex: flow spirals around a river bend, sorting sediment and substrate, depositing fines in the insides of the bends, scouring the outsides, crafting the river bed into a complex matrix of glides, pools and riffles. If the river bed and planform are intact, undercut shelves will form on the outsides of meanders at the junction between the more motile bed substrate and the more cohesive floodplain soils. These undercuts are incredibly valuable habitat for fish, especially large salmonids. The loosely triangular river bed section that evolves in a meandering channel maintains water velocities as flows lessen through the summer, whereas the uniform bed of a modified channel does not. The natural meanders therefore support plants like ranunculus and in tandem this promotes a healthy scour of the river bed, keeping fines on the move whilst creating a wide variety of habitat niches for invertebrates, benthic (eg. bullheads and minnows) and rheophilic (eg. trout, and dace) fish.

But I’ve also noticed how grazing animals like ponies interact differently with a meandering channel. The River Nar through Castle Acre was a typical straightened, modified, perched and dredged channel. Like all chalk streams subjected to these modifications it had evolved a monoculture of phragmites and bur reed along the edges (in the worst cases right across the channel) which – because they are silty death traps – grazing animals tend to avoid, nibbling only the edges, which they can reach from the safety of solid ground.

After we restored the meandering channel with river bed much closer to floodplain level, the Konik ponies that graze the common started to graze the point-bars on the insides of the bends in a different way from the more cliff-like edges on the outsides of the bends. The planform created a diversity of grazing pressure which in itself will have been beneficial to biodiversity.

It is obvious, also, that if you take the gradient out of an already low gradient stream and then massively increase the sediment loading – as we have done in the modern landscape – you will turn the stream into a silty grow-bag. When passionate river-kin types rail at the state of a chalk stream, at the gloopy silt, filamentous algae, opaque water and feeble flows, they are railing much more at its physical state than any abstraction or water quality pressure. Not to diminish the impacts of these pressures, which can be over-riding in some settings, but where there is tolerable flow (even if there is some abstraction) and water quality (even if there is some eutrophication and sediment load) the XYZ is by far the most important part of the chalk stream health. It is certainly the the foundational layer and oftentimes the easiest to sort out.

Deficit x opportunity = strategy priority. A tool for planning chalk stream catchment restoration

I’m honoured to have been asked to chair the Test and Itchen Catchment Partnership (Strategic Leadership Group) and help efforts to create a re-booted catchment restoration strategy spearheaded by the Wessex Rivers Trust and Hampshire and Isle of Wight Wildlife Trusts in partnership with all the key stakeholders, landowners, fisheries interests, water company, regulators and local groups.

These two rivers are the jewels in the English chalk stream crown (and I say that as a Norfolk lad) of iconic national and international importance. Collectively the partnership has formulated a restoration vision that is to:

“to restore these rivers to a state where natural processes, ecology and biodiversity are maximised and human impacts minimised: to create rivers and floodplains that are havens for abundant wildlife, that help manage floods, store carbon and intercept sediment, that retain their extraordinary cultural value, and that are resilient to the pressures that lie ahead”

That’s a high ambition and to use a cliché … words are cheap. Turning it into reality is the hard part. What I have learned from trying to do exactly the above (albeit at a smaller scale) on chalk streams in Norfolk is the immense value of a really good plan, one that is simple, doable and relentlessly correlated to reality.

Without a plan there are a zillion rabbit holes one can vanish down. A great deal of money can be spent doing the wrong things well, or doing the right things badly, or fixing an enormously expensive minor issue at the expense of a much more resolvable major issue. And so on.

So, I’ve been working on a methodology for constructing a restoration strategy that is simple, objective, repeatable, that makes use of existing datasets and assessments but reassembles the information in such a way as to clear signals about what to fix, where and in what order. A catchment restoration planning tool, if you like.

I sketched out the idea at the inaugural meeting of the Test and Itchen Strategic Leadership Group last week, to an exacting audience of river restoration experts, ecologists, regulators and various other key decision makers and was very pleasantly surprised by the positive reception.

I’ve set out the concept below: a) as a simple graphic and b) as a longer text explainer. I’d be very happy to incorporate feedback to help make it as useable and useful as possible.

Something’s actually happening, Reg! Abstraction reduction in the Chilterns.

Above: The River Chess in June 2025, a river whose story is a beacon of hope in the long struggle to restore our chalk streams

Chalks Streams First – as regular readers will know – is a radical but pragmatic way to realign abstraction pressure in chalk streams, allowing the streams “first” use of their water, without removing the water from the public supply network. 

The idea was conceived and theoretically tested by John Lawson using the catchments of the Colne and Lea as examples. I joined in with John to help give the idea traction with Ofwat, the EA and eNGOs. There is now a Chalk Streams First coalition of eNGOs who support the concept and variations on the idea have been absorbed into regional planning, albeit few have been fully realised as yet.

Chalk Streams First works by greatly reducing aquifer abstraction in chalk stream headwaters and upper valleys – the cheap and easy way to abstract water – and moving the point of abstraction to the lower, less environmentally sensitve reaches of the same catchments, where it is taken from the surface flow and recirculated, via reservoirs, treatment and network infrastructure to the places formerly supplied by the groundwater abstraction.

Across the full hydrological cycle a large % of the water not taken from the aquifer will manifest as surface flow (known as flow recovery) but that % is much higher in winter (over 100%) than summer (25% to 40%). Hence the need for the reservoir which stores that winter excess and becomes, essentially, a man-made version of the aquifer.

It’s the water resources verison of cakeism. Rivers and taps continue to flow.

There are a number of theoretical variations on this general concept of cakeism: for example, the upper valley groundwater abstraction could feasibly be replaced by lower valley groundwater abstraction where the rises and falls in the water table are much smaller, and the supply more reliable in summer. 

It is this version of the concept that is currently being developed by Affinity Water. Affinity Water’s central region operates largely to the north-west of London and historically has been very much reliant on chalk aquifer abstraction from the chalk hills of Bucks and Herts: the Misbourne, Colne, Lee and Stort units in the map below.

To date, Affinity – which supplies 970 million litres of water per day to almost 4-million people – has reduced its take from chalk groundwater sources by 100 Ml/d by investing in new assets and network reinforcement and increasing imports from Grafham and Ardleigh reservoirs.

Stream by stream these reductions have amounted to:

  • Hughenden Stream – a 100% reduction of 1.6 Ml/d
  • Misbourne – a 50% reduction of 13 Ml/d
  • Upper Chess – a 100% reduction of 6.38 Ml/d
  • Upper Gade – a 31% reduction of 6.4 Ml/d
  • Ver – a 67% reduction of 28 Ml/d
  • Upper Lea – a 27% reduction of 10.2 Ml/d
  • Hiz and Oughton – a 13% reduction of 1.3 Ml/d
  • Mimram – a 50% reduction of 9 Ml/d
  • Beane – a 70% reduction of 16 Ml/d

Of course many of those reductions were from very high totals. For example the Ver’s once total abstraction of 42 Ml/d was well over half the catchment recharge in an average year, meaning the 15 Ml/d still abstracted remains a high % of the stream’s recharge. We (Chalk Streams First) have argued that “sustainable” abstraction should generally amount to no more than 10% of aquifer recharge, ideally less.

However, Affinity hasn’t finished. In AMP8 it will be cracking on with a further 35 Ml/d of reduction from the chalk streams feeding the Colne, including 14 Ml/d of license relocation following the Chalk Streams First principle, which is allowing Affinity to fast-forward these reductions before other strategic resource options (ie reservoirs and transfers) come online.

Planned reductions in AMP9 are also very encouraging, totalling 45 Ml/d.

Affinity deffo deserves credit for pursuing these reductions in the face of severe logistical dificulties and contortions. They inherited a system that was developed in a different era when the resource was thought to be more than abundant. Times have changed. Affinity Water must continue to supply water – its primary statuory duty – whilst finding an environmentally more sensitive way to do it.

The battle aint over, however. The ecological response of the streams will be carefully monitored and the inclination – I’m fairly sure of this – will be to suggest that the response has not been as good as expected. That’s because the economic forces and need to supply water are urgent and are only going one way but also because it is very difficult to tease apart all the environmental stresses on chalk streams and ascribe cause and effect to only one.

The real point is that to get the best value from the investments necessary to reduce and relocate abstraction we MUST also ensure that the water in the streams and aquifers is clean and that physical habitat is restored. Only when all three happen can we expect to see true ecological recovery.

Meanwhile, congrats and chapeau to Affinity Water, for engaging so positively with the chalk stream restoration strategy. The trout will thank you. Maybe one day, the salmon!

A lovely wild trout (caught by yours truly) from the River Chess.

Update on the River Stiffkey

I’ve been back to the River Stiffkey a few times over the past few weeks to see how the newly created “natural” channel is evolving.

This is a section of a Norfolk chalk streams that curls around the edge of an Iron Age hill-fort. It was radically straightened several hundred years ago and subsequently dredged into a deep culvert.

The Norfolk Rivers Trust and Holkham Estate asked me to design a restored, natural channel to take the river back to where it used to flow. All sorts of good things should follow a project like this: a restored channel will be good for bird-life, for trout and sea trout, for invertebrates and for the diversity of plant species. It should be good for flood management and carbon sequestration too.

This is a simplified overview of the design I produced, about 2km of river from top to bottom (the flow direction is up the page!)

We executed the work in two phases in 2023 and 24. Here the diggers start work:

The excavators at work in 2023.

And here we place out “large woody debris” to give a bit of structure to the new channel:

Adding LWD to the channel.

Already the changes are visible on google maps: below is a before and after of the satellite imagery. The keen-eyed will see the clues in the floodplain as to where parts of the natural channel once flowed. And now flow again.

The Stiffkey floodplain around Warham before we started work
The Stiffkey floodplain around Warham after the new channels were finished in 2024

We were lucky in that the winter flows that followed the 2023 phase were very strong and this gave the river a chance to self-adjust. It also showed the river working naturally and that vital relationship between the river and its riparian space: just fantastic for wading birds.

Winter flows and a working floodplain in the spring of 2024.

By the summer of 2024 the first phase looked radically different than the weed-choked channel it had replaced:

Summer 2023: the is the ditch-like channel choked with burr-reed that the River Stiffkey had become where it “flowed” past the Warham fort.
September 2024 a year after the channel was excavated. None of these in-stream macrophytes were planted. It’s amazing how quickly habitat develops if you restore the correct physical state.

But these restoration projects must also be seen in terms of longer time-lines and here it is really interesting to see whether trees come back to the site and if so, which species. A mosaic of tree cover and open grassland / fen will be the secret to the long-term resilience of the project. So, it is really encouraging to see some trees springing up and fascinating to discover that they are mostly … hazel.

2025 and now 2026 have seen lower flows and I have been interested to see how the habitat has developed. Unsurprisingly, the riparian vegetation has crept out over the channel but even so, there is no choking of burr-reed, because the bed of the river is a constant gradient: there are no sumps.

This photo was taken in June 26: the river looking verdant and lively in spite of the dry weather.
This photo was taken a few weeks later, as the drought deepened. We desperately need rain, but the habitat is still holding out.

River Wrongs

Pinged to my Instagram feed one day after my last post, here’s a great example of how Paul Powlesland’s exemplar have-a-go river heroism could quickly go wrong when the heroes don’t know what they don’t know.

Here a farmer and local politician speaks on behalf of the residents of Exford arguing that the channel through the town should be stripped clean to prevent flooding. Other posts of his expand on the theme also show very well intentioned concern but a slightly misfiring understanding of what really causes flooding. As do the comments.

Of course rain can skim off Exmoor in a terrible hurry, so I get the concern. But the ability of a channel to handle water in a big flood has much more do with its capacity to convey flow than its capacity to hold volume. The rain comes down so fast that it will fill any volume you give it, if it can’t get away fast enough.

The easiest way to understand this is to think about flood water as traffic: if there’s an accident that closes all but one lane of the southbound M3 on a sunny Bank Holiday, it would make no difference if you turned the M3 into a fifty lane runway upstream of the constriction: the traffic would quickly fill the available space. The problem is the constriction. And of course the amount of traffic, the rate of flow.

In Exford, the constriction is the bridge and – to an important degree in moderate floods – the culverted channel. While the rate of flow is determined by how hard it rains and how quickly that rain skims off Exmoor. Stripping all the vegetation out of the channel in Exford would make a tiny difference in a big flood, but it would make a big difference to the habitat, day to day.

And it’s not just the middle of Exford that the concerned farmer wants to be cleared. Elsewhere he argues that the Environment Agency should be “maintaining” the rivers everywhere, by which he seems to mean old school dredging them and clearing: works that would actually accelerate the rate of flow towards Exford. It’s such a challenge trying to show that traditional ways of “controlling” flooding can often make the flooding worse, if they hurry the rate of flow from hills to the sea. There will always be constrictions, so what you really want to do is slow the rate at which water meets them and flatten the peak off the discharge.

I totally understand the anxiety. I know Exmoor well, especially the River Lyn which infamously flooded with deadly violence in 1952. That flood was caused by Biblical rain – 9 inches in 24 hours – that brought with it landslips, debris and trees: these jammed at the various bridges along the river, backing up the torrential flow, until each one burst in turn, sending waves of water down the steep valley. In Lynmouth itself the culverted river channel filled with debris and broke out into the town.

Events like this are not prevented by regularly stripping bare all the habitat that enables trout and salmon to exist. This farmer cares deeply, but thinks the answer is a long reach excavator. It isn’t. There’s definitely a case for making sure the middle of Exford is not a pinch-point and in an ideal world one might think about that bridge. But if I was a concerned resident of Exford, I’d be looking upstream at the ways in which the river and tributaries have been modified over the years and how we might make the landscape more absorbent and slow the rate of run off.

River Rights & Wrongs

In some ways eco-warrior Paul Powlesland has the sort of zeal we need much more of. He cares enough about an overlooked London river to spend his own money trying to improve it. So, when the Environment Agency wrote to him warning that it was investigating works he’d done on the Alders Brook without a permit, it looked once again like a bureaucracy that had lost its purpose, persecuting someone trying to do the right thing.

I met Paul briefly a couple of years ago after he had given a talk on the Rights of Rivers, for which he is a passionate advocate. Curious about the arguments in favour, I had nevertheless been unconvinced. I couldn’t see what the granting of rights would do to improve a river’s health over and above the application of existing (or improved) environmental laws.

This kerfuffle with the Agency hasn’t done much to sway my scepticism. In fact, it begs the same question I had wanted to ask Paul as he rushed to the train station: “Once a river has rights, who will best speak for it?” A river’s interests aren’t always that obvious and the path to hell is paved with good intentions.

The story of Powlesland’s run-in with Agency has been very widely reported: splashed across The Guardian and The Daily Telegraph, featured in Channel 4 news, retold as far afield as The Times of India and all over social media. The stories all suggest that Powlesland was being threatened with prosecution for removing rubbish from a river, which on the face of it is absurd.

That didn’t quite ring true for me. The good folk of the River Wandle Trust have been taking rubbish out of that south London river for decades, without ever falling foul of the Environment Agency. They have done this work with the cooperation of the local council, who have provided lorries to take away the vast quantities of stuff that other no-so-good folk of south London insist on throwing in there: mattresses, tyres, shopping trolleys. You name it.

Volunteers on the River Wandle have been litter-picking for years without ever falling foul of the Environment Agency.

I couldn’t imagine why on the Earth the Agency would want to harry Powlesland for litter picking, and I suspected that they didn’t. I suspected, in fact, that they had taken exception to something else. The words “silt and weed” in The Guardian headline made me suspicious. The mention in The Daily Telegraph of the use of an excavator hired by Powlesland for £750 made me more suspicious. You don’t need an excavator to pick litter. So, had he actually dredged the river of “silt and weed” in the name of cleaning it up?

Sure enough, when the Agency finally relented and informed Powlesland that they wouldn’t be taking further action the letter alluded to “flood risk activity” consisting of “dredging, raising or taking of any sand, silt, ballast, clay, gravel off the bed or banks of the Alder’s Brook”. Somewhere on the Roding Trust Facebook feed there is a film of a digger slubbing mud out of the channel. Harmless enough, perhaps, but ordinary mortals do need consent for that kind of work, so to just crack on without it and post the evidence …

Clearly, Powlesland is very much motivated to do the right thing. Clearly, he is frustrated by what he sees as petty-fogging bureaucracy standing in his way.         

But so was John Price, a farmer who was jailed for 12 months for taking an excavator into the River Lugg and dredging the bed of that highly protected river. John Price’s crime was far, far worse than Powlesland’s intervention, but the point is … John Price thought he was doing the right thing too. He thought he was protecting the village from flooding. And the media, en masse, portrayed him as a Robin Hood hero. He wasn’t. He badly damaged salmon spawning grounds, and if anything, his tidying up of the River Lugg will have made the flooding worse.

Powlesland’s work on the Alders Brook won’t have done either of those things, but if he dredged silt out of it he may have temporarily stirred up pollutants and caused oxygen depletion downstream. Besides, dredging silt out of the Alders Brook is also a Canute-like exercise.

The Alders Brook is not a tributary of the River Roding, as described in the newspaper reports. It is the natural course of the upper reaches of the tidal River Roding. Further down the valley the same relic natural course was once called The Back Water and is now almost entirely erased. The first edition Ordnance Survey marks the head of the Alders Brook where it leaves the diverted course of the modern River Roding, with the words “Ford. Ordinary Tides flow to this point”.         

The Alders Brook is part of the estuarial River Roding, naturally tidal upstream as far as the ford.

The diversion of the modern river course flowed from there to a paper mill in the village of Great Ilford. No doubt the paper mill is long since obsolete but the modified course and its impact on river morphology remains. The Alders Brook is not a free-flowing stream, rather a part relic of a tidal estuary. Once it would have drained under gravity twice a day, and this would have kept its main channel free of accumulating sediment. But estuaries are, by their nature, muddy places where any interruption to gradient will gather silt and mud. The upper parts the Alders Brook have natural gradient, but the lowermost reach takes a sharp, unnatural turn to the east, and if anything, the river is trying to climb uphill as it rejoins the much diverted and much modified main Roding. It is, therefore, a sump and will always fill with silt.

A LiDAR image of the Alders Brook – the thin, meandering line in the centre. Its ability to transport sediment is now severely compromised by a railway line and diversion at the downstream end. The railway and the infrastructure around it form what is, essentially, a dam across the valley floor.

Throughout eastern England, we’ve done stuff like this: we have boxed in estuarial reaches of rivers and reclaimed the land either side of them. Now, they can be miles from the sea with all vestiges of that transient landscape buried under trading estates, retail parks and railway lines, and the expectation is that these meandering courses should behave like rivers. They can’t.

Removing accumulated silt may look like restoration, but unless the free-flowing tidal processes that once maintained the channel are also fully restored—which, in urban east London, is impossible —the exercise becomes one of perpetual maintenance.

None of this is to question Powlesland’s motives, which are clearly driven by a passion to improve his local river. But that doesn’t mean every enthusiastic intervention should simply be waved on through without the troubling business of conforming to the consenting process.

And it does beg a question about river rights. In the few places these have been enacted they’re just too vague to be meaningful: “the right to flow” “the right to be free from pollution”. For all our failures to actually impose environmental laws, these laws protect rivers in terms that are generally much clearer.

Rights would require somebody to speak on behalf of the rights-holder and who is best going to do that when one person’s idea of an improvement may be another person’s idea of environmental damage? A river that looks untidy may actually be a haven for wildlife. A fallen tree might look like obstruction, when it’s actually habitat. Silt looks dirty when it might be the stucture of the channel. Weeds look like neglect when they are vital to the flow, temperature, oxygen and nurient levels.         

Passionate river guardians standing up for vague rights and emboldened to act unilaterally without consent because they feel that right is on their side: that could just as well become an army of John Prices, as an army of Paul Powleslands. We should be careful what we wish for.

The Roding Trust volunteers go out in all weathers and do hard work to make their corner of the planet better. We need their passion, for sure. The Environment Agency were a bit heavy-hoofed in this case, and that didn’t sit well in the context of their reluctance to prosecute much more obvious and damaging environmental offences. Powlesland has described dozens of illegal discharges of raw sewage upstream on the same river: Theydon Bois works, for example, spilled 85 times in 2025. Not all of those can have been in “exceptional weather”.

But right now, if I want to restore a river I have to draw up a plan, back it with evidence and apply for permission. The application procedure is frustratingly slow and sometimes the edicts from the folk granting or denying permission feel baffling, or obstructive. I wish the process could be better and argue that it should be. But on the other hand, if we want the Environment Agency to protect rivers, then we shouldn’t object too hard when it does.

Coda.

So, if the Roding Trust can’t meaningfully restore the estuarial Alders Brook because there’s just too much of London in the way, what could they do to revive it and create a lovely waterscape? I seriously doubt the brook serves any flood relief function nowadays: so, bearing in mind it can’t become free-flowing again and will always be a silt trap, I’d cut off the inflow and outflow and turn it into a meandering still-water. This way, silt would take much, much longer to accrete and could be carefully removed once a decade by suction. It would be clear-watered and full of life and pretty enough— one hopes— to shame even the worst of litterbugs.         

The project would require consent, however.

A once tidal creek that is now a meandering, freshwater pool: an example of the best possible outcome for the modern Alder’s Brook?

Tarrant update 4 – The Environment Agency response – whistling while Rome burns.

The Environment Agency (EA) has finally replied to the River Tarrant Protection Society (RTPS). The reply doesn’t reflect well on the EA.

The RTPS is a local group, campaigning for the protection of the River Tarrant, a Dorset chalk stream that historically supported 5 Domesday watermills and even now remains a spawning stream for Atlantic salmon, but which nowadays dries all too frequently because of abstraction. The RTPS has shown that before the 1950s the steam rarely, if ever, dried in its lower reaches. After the onset of groundwater abstraction the lower stream began to dry in extreme droughts – eg 1976, 1989 – catalysing the formation of the protection society.

The situation had been bad for decades. Now it is much worse. In 2018 Wessex Water completed work on an area ring-main, designed to relieve abstraction pressure on chalk streams in the neighbouring and highly protected Avon catchment. As a result, abstraction around the River Tarrant increased, since when the stream has dried in its lower reaches every single year.

The one year in the past ten when the stream did not dry was 2017, when the local pumps were turned off, and that was in spite of the fact that 2017 was drought year for chalk streams.

The RTPS has compiled a report consisting of historical evidence, ecological evidence, local testimony and modelling that collectively – in the opinion of the RTPS – suggests that abstraction is the cause of this increased drying.

RTPS has asked for a meeting with the EA to discuss their concerns, and for the potential abstraction impacts to be investigated more fully in the next round of AMP investigations. These are hardly unreasonable requests, especially in light of the fact that Atlantic salmon from chalk streams have very recently been shown to be a genetically unique and critically endangered sub-species. In the Stour catchment the salmon are on the very edge of survival.

My past few blogs have detailed the argument and the local EA’s inflexible and partisan approach to the matter. The area office commissioned a comparative and isolated review of the approaches to groundwater modelling taken by the Wessex Water / EA teams and John Lawson, the independent hydrologist working for RTPS. The review concluded that John Lawson’s approach was too simplistic, whilst also admitting that the Wessex model did not actually perform very well in its modelling of the impacts of the Black Lane abstraction.

The local EA didn’t consider any of the other evidence. As you can see below, the EA now considers the matter closed.

[*This being the RTPS response to the EA’s review of John Lawson’s modelling]

I should leave readers to form their own conclusions given the EA’s approach somewhat speaks for itself.

But I can’t help but point out:

The RTPS didn’t ask the EA to “walk away from their groundwater model”, rather RTPS suggested that the model may not be entirely correct. Who really thinks that groundwater models are infallibly accurate?

The RTPS didn’t criticise the independent reviewer, but rather her review and more especially the limited terms of her enquiry which were set by the EA.

These are classic straw man tropes and I am surprised by them given the loss of respect and credibility that will inevitably follow.

As to the alternative explanation that the riverbed “has become more leaky”* perhaps I really should let that speak for itself!

Of course the Tarrant has become more leaky. That’s the point. The question is WHY?

*This may be one for a more detailed rebuttal in another post. The idea that the separation of water table from river bed leads to an absolutely binary transition, is nonsense. Apart from anything else, it is perfectly obvious from the flow data that the water table peels away from the river bed, and that the drying extends by varying distances upstream depending on the water balance.

One thinks of Sisyphus.

Tarrant update 3 – Known knowns, known unknowns and unknown unknowns.

A fascinating comment was recently added to my post The Slow Death of a Chalk Stream. Nick Walton – a hydrogeologist with 50 years experience – wrote: 

Given the above, said Nick, historical evidence, empirical data, local knowledge and some hydrological common sense are worth a lot and shouldn’t be dismissed. 

Those four things are exactly what the River Tarrant Protection Society report contains. The RTPS is saying that when all the evidence is taken in the round the case is strong enough to justify further, detailed and truly independent investigation. 

This shouldn’t be a debate about whether the Wessex Basin Model is more sophisticated than the CSF modelling. It clearly is. 

The issue is whether the confidence placed in the Wessex reports conclusions is justified, given the limitations of the underlying data, the acknowledged uncertainties in conceptual understanding, and the internal inconsistencies in model performance across the Pimperne and Tarrant catchments and beyond to the edge of the Stour. 

Data from an impacted system

All models are limited by the quality of the data that is fed into them — and here the data are limited and impacted. The Wessex model is built on:

  • groundwater level records (largely post-1970),
  • short-term stream flow gauging with spot meters (primarily 2015–2017)
  • short-term targeted pumping and switch-off tests,
  • a system that has been subject to decades of abstraction.

In other words, the model is based on data extracted from a system that is already altered from its natural state. 

Without continuous flow records prior to the 1970s, and without direct measurements of groundwater–surface water interactions before large-scale abstraction, surely historical and qualitative evidence becomes more, not less, important? And yet it is largely excluded from the formal assessment.

Of course, Jane Dottridge wasn’t commissioned to comment on this other evidence. She nevertheless described it as “anecdotal”. I don’t think that’s fair. Anecdotal refers to an account or short narrative that is subjective, unreliable, or hearsay. Mapped Domesday mills are not anecdotal evidence.

Pimperne calibration

As to the models: Jane critiqued the one-dimensional simplicity of the CSF conceptual model. However, in spite of its attempts to capture the more complex reality, there is still uncertainty and assumption in the Wessex model, especially around the Pimperne–Tarrant interfluve. 

Jane does highlight this: “the Pimperne calibration is not very good, with a very smooth modelled recession in contrast to the marked break in slope of the observations. Some of the gauges on the middle Tarrant (Rushton, Preston Farm) also show the same feature” 

But she makes little of it. In the next paragraph Jane writes: “The conclusions appear to be justified based on the evidence presented in the report”

I don’t follow that logic. To recap, the conclusions of the report are:

  • Tarrant: only the abstraction pump in the valley (Stubhampton) is relevant to flows in the Tarrant. The stream is negligibly impacted by this abstraction “along the perennial reach” * and the ecology is not adversely impacted.
  • Pimperne: the abstraction at Black Lane does not impact flows in the Pimperne.

That is a very clear no impact statement given: 

  • The calibration is poor in the Pimperne and the lower Tarrant. 
  • The Black Lane abstraction is a high % of the catchment recharge. 
  • The groundwater boundary is modelled as fixed with no impact on the neighbouring Tarrant.

Surely the mismatch between the strength of no impact conclusions and the poor calibration warrants a furrowed brow. 

* This is a variation on a rhetorical ploy I’ve seen before: if a stream is dry then abstraction is ipso facto not impacting the stream. It’s also evidence of my point about how the impacted state can become the new baseline. The RTPS contends that the lower river is naturally perennial.

Known knowns, known unknowns and unknown unknowns.

The Wessex report presents a conceptual model strategically refined by fieldwork that included stream-bed surveys, weekly observations and spot-flow measurements, new boreholes to investigate the interfluve, switch-off and pumping tests. 

Accordingly, the model was refined to simulate lower transmissivity beneath interfluves, higher transmissivity in valley bottoms and the introduction of “unmapped faults” in the chalk – horizontal flow barriers – to improve calibration.

Surely these iterative refinements highlight, rather than resolve, the uncertainty? The interfluve behaviour was not predicted by earlier model versions, new borehole data required significant reinterpretation of the system and the fault-line is partly imposed through model structure, inferred  – because the river dries – rather than directly observed in the geology.

The cornerstone conclusion ref the Tarrant — that abstractions outside the catchment have no impact — depends on the assumption of limited cross-interfluve connectivity. And yet groundwater catchments are known to shift with hydraulic gradients and Jane’s review confirms that groundwater boundaries can and often do vary over time and with rising and falling groundwater levels. If they do this, they can also vary because of abstraction pressure. 

A central element of the Wessex argument is that switch-off and pumping tests define what they call “zones of influence” of abstractions and that impacts are therefore spatially limited.

This interpretation is not supported by general hydrogeological principles. Why does it pass, unchallenged?

Short-duration tests reveal immediate, local drawdown responses but do not capture longer-term system adjustment. They don’t capture the delayed propagation of pressure changes, the redistribution of groundwater flow paths, or slowly accreting capture from inter-connected water bodies. 

The absence of observed drawdown at a location during a short test simply cannot be taken as evidence of no long-term hydrological impact.

Pick’n’mix

There is also evidence of expedient selectivity in the Wessex report and even Jane points this out. Where the Wessex model performs reasonably well – the Tarrant – it is used to support conclusions. Where it performs poorly – the Pimperne – then alternative methods are used: pump tests and empirical observations.

This pick’n’mix kind of undermines confidence in the whole thing surely? The analytical method is not consistent across the whole piece. 

John’s CSF model may be pilloried for its simplicity, but at least it treats the whole study area in the same way. The Wessex Water approach ought to weaken the Environment Agency’s confidence in the system-wide conclusions, particularly those relating to this cross-catchment impacts we insist are plausible but which Wessex Water hotly denies.

What about 2017?

I’ve already underlined the coincidence between a long-term shut down 2016 to 2017 of the Black Lane pump in the neighbouring Pimperne valley and the fact that the summer of 2017 was the one year in the past ten that the lower Tarrant did not dry. This is such good evidence that the Black Lane pump may well be having an impact on the Tarrant, or the Black Lane and Shapwick pumps in tandem, especially when one remembers that the spring of 2017 was bad for chalk streams. That was the year that I took photographs of drying streams all round London, the Ver, Chess, Misbourne, Beane, Rib, Ash and others.

The year the Chess looked like this, the River Tarrant kept flowing.

Wessex Water has an answer: they claim that late summer rain prevented the Tarrant from drying when it was otherwise on course to. I put this to John Lawson and he went away to look at the rainfall figures over a longer time-series, to see if this late summer rain was an anomaly that plausibly did make the difference.

As you can see, the summers of 2015, 2021 and 2023 were similarly wet or wetter than 2017, but the river still dried. Whereas the the preceding October 2016 to March 2017 was unusually dry and that’s what usually determines flows in the following summer.

In summary

There is a mismatch between limited range of data (no consistent, long-term flow gauging), incomplete understanding of the aquifer, poor calibration in the modelling and confidence in the conclusions.

The purpose of highlighting these issues is not to suggest that “we are right and Wessex Water and the Environment Agency are wrong”. Instead it is to demonstrate that:

  • alternative models produce plausible results which do suggest an abstraction impact,
  • key assumptions (e.g. fixed catchment boundaries, limited zones of influence) are not definitively proven,
  • the current evidence base does not support a strong “no impact” conclusion.

Given all the above surely it would be prudent to treat the current findings as provisional rather than definitive and look for a more robust truly independent investigation, with scope not limited to model comparison.

Let’s not forget, this stream is used for spawning by Atlantic salmon. The stream may not be as protected as the Bourne and Wylye, but the salmon is. These fish are genetically unique to chalk streams and the Stour’s population of these fish must be the most endangered stock of all.

Oh and just one more thing …

Underlining the mismatch between what we know and confidence in conclusions, it is worth addicting that recent research into the Chalk aquifer by Andy Farrant and others at the BGS has highlighted the greater-than-previously-recognised role of karstic dissolution features and preferential flow pathways in chalk. These can provide localised areas of enhanced permeability that are not necessarily captured in regional groundwater models. Hydraulic connectivity may well occur along pathways that are not predicted by averaged aquifer properties or detected by limited observation boreholes. This must be relevant where abstraction alters hydraulic gradients, potentially activating or enhancing flow along such pathways?

Sure, this does not demonstrate that such connections exist between the Pimperne and Tarrant catchments, it does underline the uncertainty associated with assuming that lower-transmissivity interfluves act as hard hydraulic boundaries.

Just saying …